(13 Sep 2024)
Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) has long claimed that detainers, often called
"immigration holds," are an essential tool needed to apprehend and deport individuals not
authorized to remain in the U.S.
ICE detainers are often used as one indicator of the intensity of what is called “interior
enforcement” in contrast to “border enforcement” conducted by ICE’s peer agency, Customs and Border
Protection (CBP). The latest detainer-by-detainer internal ICE records recently received by the
Transactional Records Access Clearinghouse (TRAC) provide details on how the use of detainers has been
climbing under the current Biden administration. Since February 2023, agency officials have regularly
issued more than 10,000 each month.
From FY 2021 through the first quarter of FY 2024, the current administration issued just under
300,000 detainers. These have been addressed to 4,305 different law enforcement agencies. Among law
enforcement agencies (LEAs) receiving ICE detainers under the current administration, those in
California received the largest number, followed closely by LEAs in Texas. ICE officials issued
detainers in over 10,000 separate cases in Houston, Texas, more than any other city in the country.
With over 7,800 detainers, LEAs in Los Angeles, California, cumulatively had the second-most
issuances, while LEAs in Phoenix, Arizona, together had the third highest with over 6,600.
Although detainer usage under the Biden administration has been rising, 50 percent more ICE detainers
were issued during the Trump presidency (FY 2017 - FY 2020). However, the number of different LEAs
which were issued detainers was roughly comparable between the Biden and Trump administrations. That
is, dispersion of detainer usage across communities in the U.S. was similar, although the specifics of
which communities had law enforcement agencies receiving detainers differed somewhat between the two
administrations.
Los Angeles, California (20,318 detainers issued) tops the list for Trump, followed closely by
Houston, Texas (19,289). Phoenix, Arizona with 17,294 detainers issued during the four years of the
Trump presidency was in third place. Just twelve (12) cities in the country received 5,000 or more
detainers during the Trump years. A total of twenty-five (25) cities received 3,000 or more.
Most of these top 25 communities received more detainers during the Trump years, but this was not true
for all communities. San Francisco, California received 2 percent fewer detainers by Trump than Biden
and Van Nuys, California received 4 percent fewer detainers during the Trump administration. The full
report identifies 25 additional communities receiving a greater number of detainers during the Biden
presidency.
The report contains a series of detailed maps of the United States that pinpoint each city or town
where ICE issued a detainer to a local law enforcement agency during the Biden and Trump
administrations. Accompanying the report is a public dashboard providing details by month covering the
last two decades for each ICE detainer issued as disaggregated by the county, state, name of each LEA,
as well as the demographic and background characteristics of the noncitizens each concerned.
TRAC is a self-supporting, nonpartisan, and independent research organization specializing in
data collection and analysis on federal enforcement, staffing, and spending. We produce multiple
reports every month on critical issues, and we also provide comprehensive data analysis tools.
|
To know more about our work, click
here.
|
|