<< Back to: "Seeing Justice Done: The Impact of the Judge on Sentencing

Table 2. Judge-to-Judge Differences in Average and Median Prison Sentence,
January 2014 - December 2018

District Courthouse Number of U.S. District Court Judges Prison Sentence Range (Months) Between Lowest-Highest Judge's
Median Sentences Average Sentences
Ala, M Montgomery 2 1.0 0.2
Ala, N Birmingham 7 18.0 25.6
Ala, S Mobile 4 24.5 22.2
Alaska Anchorage 3 11.0 6.8
Arizona Phoenix 12 28.0 32.7
Arizona Tucson 7 9.0 12.7
Ark, E Little Rock 7 10.5 17.3
Cal, C Los Angeles 17 30.5 32.8
Cal, C Riverside 2 24.0 33.4
Cal, C Santa Ana 5 13.0 10.3
Cal, E Fresno 3 13.5 12.1
Cal, E Sacramento 6 9.5 16.5
Cal, N Oakland 2 0.0 5.8
Cal, N San Francisco 9 32.5 39.4
Cal, N San Jose 3 9.0 9.6
Cal, S San Diego 17 12.0 17.5
Colorado Denver 10 14.0 27.0
Conn Bridgeport 4 21.0 25.1
Conn Hartford 5 18.5 19.3
D. C. DC 8 11.0 23.7
Delaware Wilmington 4 22.0 22.9
Fla, M Ft. Myers 2 3.0 6.9
Fla, M Jacksonville 5 18.0 22.9
Fla, M Orlando 7 52.0 80.2
Fla, M Tampa 9 48.0 59.7
Fla, N Pensacola 2 6.0 14.6
Fla, N Tallahassee 2 1.5 1.3
Fla, S Ft. Lauderdale 4 5.0 6.4
Fla, S Miami 13 19.0 28.6
Fla, S West Palm Beach 4 16.5 2.0
Ga, M Albany 2 7.5 12.5
Ga, M Macon 3 16.0 15.6
Ga, N Atlanta 9 24.0 42.9
Ga, S Augusta 2 10.0 0.3
Ga, S Savannah 2 20.0 32.3
Hawaii Honolulu 5 18.0 31.9
Idaho Boise 2 0.0 5.8
Ill, C Peoria 3 18.0 18.9
Ill, C Urbana 2 24.0 20.4
Ill, N Chicago 21 33.0 30.5
Ill, N Rockford 2 5.0 9.4
Ill, S Benton 2 48.0 32.9
Ill, S East St. Louis 3 2.5 10.8
Ind, N Hammond 4 3.0 16.7
Ind, N South Bend 2 6.0 4.4
Ind, S Indianapolis 4 16.0 17.2
Iowa, N Sioux City 2 10.0 0.1
Iowa, S Des Moines 4 39.0 37.3
Kansas Kansas City 2 12.0 22.9
Kansas Topeka 3 14.0 18.4
Kansas Wichita 2 36.0 45.1
Ken, E Lexington 2 2.0 2.4
Ken, E London 2 18.0 22.5
Ken, W Louisville 3 14.5 10.6
La, E New Orleans 8 23.5 20.7
La, M Baton Rouge 4 12.5 13.2
La, W Shreveport 3 26.5 22.0
Maine Portland 4 9.5 21.0
Maryland Baltimore 8 30.0 41.0
Maryland Greenbelt 7 45.0 64.3
Mass Boston 11 28.0 33.9
Mass Worcester 2 12.0 12.1
Mich, E Ann Arbor 2 5.0 12.4
Mich, E Detroit 18 18.0 40.8
Mich, E Flint 2 0.5 9.1
Mich, W Grand Rapids 4 18.0 15.1
Minnesota Minneapolis 6 12.5 17.0
Minnesota St. Paul 3 10.5 15.2
Miss, N Aberdeen 2 4.0 1.7
Miss, N Oxford 2 1.0 3.7
Miss, S Gulfport 2 0.0 3.6
Miss, S Jackson 4 15.0 7.4
Mo, E St. Louis 8 13.5 18.7
Mo, W Kansas City 9 20.0 34.4
Montana Missoula 2 27.0 27.2
N Car, E Raleigh 2 7.0 13.3
N Car, M Greensboro 3 6.0 7.1
N Car, M Winston Salem 2 13.0 10.1
N Car, W Asheville 2 4.0 12.9
N Car, W Charlotte 3 27.0 18.7
N Mexico Albuquerque 8 27.3 38.6
N Mexico Las Cruces 2 0.1 0.8
N. J. Camden 5 17.0 12.0
N. J. Newark 10 34.5 23.7
N. J. Trenton 5 26.5 26.7
N. Y., E Brooklyn 18 18.0 58.7
N. Y., E Central Islip 6 21.0 21.1
N. Y., N Albany 3 18.5 21.8
N. Y., N Syracuse 3 6.0 21.5
N. Y., S Manhattan 30 37.0 47.2
N. Y., S White Plains 4 9.0 20.3
N. Y., W Buffalo 3 15.0 14.4
N. Y., W Rochester 4 30.0 27.8
Nebraska Lincoln 2 6.0 6.9
Nebraska Omaha 4 6.0 5.4
Nevada Las Vegas 7 31.0 27.7
Nevada Reno 4 11.0 12.2
New Hamp Concord 5 14.5 15.6
Ohio, N Akron 2 6.0 1.8
Ohio, N Cleveland 6 15.0 19.4
Ohio, N Toledo 3 7.0 6.4
Ohio, S Cincinnati 2 0.0 4.1
Ohio, S Columbus 6 16.0 16.0
Ohio, S Dayton 3 3.0 10.3
Okla, N Tulsa 3 15.0 8.6
Okla, W Oklahoma City 6 12.0 13.8
Oregon Eugene 2 12.0 9.6
Oregon Portland 6 24.0 35.1
Penn, E Allentown 3 12.0 22.9
Penn, E Philadelphia 22 52.0 58.5
Penn, E Reading 2 18.5 14.9
Penn, M Harrisburg 5 14.5 19.7
Penn, M Scranton 5 31.5 28.0
Penn, W Pittsburgh 9 22.5 24.9
Puer Rico Hato Rey, Puerto Rico 8 16.0 17.1
R. I. Providence 3 12.5 8.0
S Car Charleston 3 12.0 6.2
S Car Columbia 3 34.0 52.0
S Car Florence 2 20.0 31.7
S Car Greenville 4 16.0 14.4
Tenn, E Chattanooga 3 9.0 7.2
Tenn, E Knoxville 4 27.5 36.8
Tenn, M Nashville 5 9.5 9.9
Tenn, W Memphis 6 27.0 37.6
Texas, E Beaumont 3 31.0 28.1
Texas, E Sherman 2 14.0 12.0
Texas, E Tyler 2 14.0 1.4
Texas, N Dallas 8 27.0 36.6
Texas, N Fort Worth 2 32.0 39.2
Texas, S Brownsville 4 6.0 10.7
Texas, S Corpus Christi 3 9.0 15.4
Texas, S Houston 12 18.0 22.8
Texas, S Laredo 3 2.0 4.2
Texas, S McAllen 3 6.0 8.3
Texas, W Austin 2 9.0 19.1
Texas, W Del Rio 2 1.0 9.1
Texas, W El Paso 5 2.0 2.9
Texas, W Midland 2 11.0 9.2
Texas, W San Antonio 4 4.0 10.6
Utah Salt Lake City 9 39.0 34.4
Vermont Rutland 2 4.0 1.8
Virg, E Alexandria 7 6.5 12.1
Virg, E Norfolk 6 24.0 27.8
Virg, E Richmond 5 44.5 45.3
Virg, W Roanoke 3 3.0 9.2
W Virg, N Wheeling 2 1.5 1.0
W Virg, S Charleston 3 14.0 16.3
Wash, E Richland 2 11.0 9.3
Wash, E Spokane 4 9.0 18.9
Wash, E Yakima 2 14.0 19.1
Wash, W Seattle 7 13.0 12.6
Wash, W Tacoma 3 10.5 3.0
Wisc, E Milwaukee 5 25.0 17.6
Wisc, W Madison 3 16.0 11.7
Wyoming Cheyenne 2 3.0 4.6