Judge-by-Judge Asylum Decisions in Immigration Courts FY 2007

			Denial Rate
Immigration Court	Judge	Decisions	% Grants	% Denials
Adelanto	Lee, Amy T.	367	8.2	91.8
	Everett, Timothy R.	290	8.6	91.4
	McGrail, Elizabeth H.	282	11	89
	Dorfman, Arlene E.	136	14.7	85.3
	Burke, David H.	216	23.6	76.4
	Laurent, Scott D.	129	24.8	75.2
Arlington	Harris, Rodger C.	312	11.5	88.5
	Owens, Robert P.	118	60.2	39.8
	Snow, Thomas G.	1024	70.5	29.5
	Iskra, Wayne R.	487	74.5	25.5
	Burman, Lawrence O.	789	77.1	22.9
	Bryant, John Milo	499	82.4	17.6
	Schmidt, Paul W.	488	82.6	17.4
Atlanta	Wilson, Earle B.	903	2.3	97.7
	Cassidy, William A.	195	5.6	94.4
	Garcia, Madeline	153	11.8	88.2
	Pelletier, Jonathan D.	333	15	85
	Houser, Wayne K., Jr.	154	29.2	70.8
Aurora	Vandello, James P.	108	3.7	96.3
	Livingston, Donn L.	125	22.4	77.6
Baltimore	Williams, Phillip T.	923	41.8	58.2
	Kessler, Elizabeth A.	542	48.9	51.1
	Dornell, Lisa	547	56.7	43.3
	Gossart, John F., Jr.	371	57.1	42.9
	Crosland, David W.	929	58.8	41.2
	Slavin, Denise N.	156	97.4	2.6
Bloomington	Nickerson, William J., Jr.	253	2.8	97.2
	Olmanson, Kristin W.	375	26.4	73.6
	Conley de Castro, Susan E.	425	28.2	71.8
Boston	Harris, Rodger C.	153	43.1	56.9
	O'Malley, Brenda M.	447	55.7	44.3
	Feder, Robin E.	431	61	39
	Shapiro, Leonard I.	275	61.5	38.5
	Klein, Eliza C.	107	63.6	36.4
	Gagnon, Paul M.	284	65.5	34.5
	D'Angelo, Matthew J.	392	69.1	30.9
	O'Sullivan, Maureen S.	155	80.6	19.4
Buffalo	Connelly, Steven J.	202	12.9	87.1
	Reid, John B.	181	17.1	82.9
	Montante, Philip J., Jr	174	23.6	76.4
Charlotte	Pettinato, Barry J.	523	15.5	84.5
	Couch, V. Stuart	386	18.4	81.6
	Holmes-Simmons, Theresa	282	28.4	71.6
Chicago	DiMarzio, Philip L.	187	4.3	95.7
	Zerbe, Craig M.	310	42.3	57.7
	Vinikoor, Robert D.	527	45.2	54.8
	Perez-Guzman, Virginia	346	55.5	44.5
	Giambastiani, Jennie L.	354	56.2	43.8
	McNulty, Sheila	228	57.5	42.5
	Cuevas, Carlos	291	59.1	40.9
Cleveland	Evans, D. William, Jr.	436	10.1	89.9
	Janas, Thomas	412	18	82
	Brown, Alison M.	534	37.5	62.5
Dallas	Sims, Deitrich H.	251	6.8	93.2
	Kimball, R. Wayne	393	20.6	79.4
	Ozmun, Richard R.	313	21.7	78.3
	Baird, Michael P.	254	30.7	69.3
Denver	Tsankov, Mimi	194	36.1	63.9
	Livingston, Donn L.	304	41.8	58.2
	Cordova, David J.	177	46.9	53.1
	Trujillo, Eileen R.	204	64.7	35.3
Detroit	Hacker, Elizabeth A.	104	18.3	81.7
	Newberry, Robert D.	320	19.1	80.9
	Nettles, Marsha K.	200	25	75
	Paruch, David H.	328	29	71
El Paso	Mahtabfar, Sunita B.	159	0.6	99.4
	Roepke, Thomas C.	233	1.3	98.7
	Gonzalez, Guadalupe R.	101	3	97
	Ruhle, Stephen M.	231	3.9	96.1
	Abbott, William L.	318	6.3	93.7
Elizabeth	Tadal, Mirlande	496	27.8	72.2
	Harbeck, Dorothy A.	384	55.2	44.8
Eloy	DeVitto, James Alan	153	2.6	97.4
	Feldman, Irene C.	195	5.6	94.4
	Spencer-Walters, Linda Inez	236	8.5	91.5
	Phelps, Richard A.	167	9.6	90.4
Florence	Taylor, Bruce A.	244	8.2	91.8
	Arellano, Silvia R.	163	9.8	90.2
Hagatna	Beamer, Dayna M.	117	49.6	50.4
Harlingen	Ayala, David	257	41.2	58.8
	Tovar, Eleazar	136	52.2	47.8
Hartford	Straus, Michael W.	563	27.4	72.6
	Verrillo, Philip	329	55.3	44.7
Honolulu	Wagner, Clarence M., Jr.	282	63.5	36.5
	Beamer, Dayna M.	607	73.6	26.4
Houston	Harris, Monique	501	4	96
	Bhagat, Nimmo	635	11.5	88.5
	Luis, Lisa	111	12.6	87.4
	Endelman, Gary E.	643	13.8	86.2
	Walton, Richard D.	224	14.3	85.7
	Brisack, Chris A.	299	20.7	79.3
	Rankin Yates, Clarease Rankin	261	33.3	66.7
Houston - Detained	Rose, Howard	110	0	100
	Walton, Richard D.	137	3.6	96.4
	Greenstein, Saul	218	11.9	88.1
	Benton, Jimmie L.	116	12.9	87.1
Imperial	Staton, Jack W.	259	13.5	86.5
Kansas City	O'Malley, John R.	248	30.6	69.4
	Davis, Paula V.	314	36.6	63.4
Las Vegas	Romig, Jeffrey L.	493	11.4	88.6
	Mullins, Ronald L.	145	16.6	83.4
Los Angeles	Munoz, Lorraine J.	759	2.9	97.1
	Ruane, Rachel A.	216	7.4	92.6
	Walsh, John F.	367	8.4	91.6
	Anderson, David C.	213	10.3	89.7
	Riley, Kevin W.	730	10.4	89.6
	Naselow-Nahas, Tara	1014	14	86
	Maury, Carlos E.	105	14.3	85.7
	Ho, Anna	285	23.5	76.5
	Tabaddor, Afsaneh Ashley	598	26.3	73.7
	O'Connor, Lee A.	428	26.6	73.4
	Peters, Rose C.	317	29	71
	Giattina, Anthony T.	265	29.1	70.9
	Latimore, Jan D.	385	29.4	70.6
	Rooyani, Rodin	391	29.9	70.1
	Bither, Christine A.	247	32.4	67.6
	Travieso, Frank M.	385	35.6	64.4
	Parchert, Brett M.	574	37.8	62.2
	Stancill, Christine E.	735	40.8	59.2
	Hong, J. Traci	109	43.1	56.9
	Little, Monica M.	465	43.4	56.6
	Dunkel-Bradley, Dorothy A.	339	43.7	56.3
	Burke, David H.	150	44	56
	Bank, Ira E.	451	44.3	55.7
	Sitgraves, Darcy D.	495	44.6	55.4
	Dorfman, Arlene E.	290	45.5	54.5
	Bass, Lori R.	301	50.2	49.8
	Costa, Philip J.	469	50.5	49.5
	Coughlon, Robert E.	162	56.8	43.2
	Vahid-Tehrani, Gita	457	60.4	39.6
	O'Sullivan, Maureen S.	469	63.3	36.7
	Bakke Varzandeh, Joyce A.	349	69.6	30.4
	Neumeister, David	408	69.9	30.1
	Sholomson, Stephen L.	124	78.2	21.8
Los Fresnos	Hunsucker, Keith E.	572	22	78
	Powell, Robert L.	556	24.8	75.2
	Achtsam, Howard E.	243	25.5	74.5
Lumpkin	Arrington, Saundra H.	214	3.7	96.3
	Trimble, Dan	265	4.2	95.8
Memphis	Kaufman, Matthew W.	168	15.5	84.5
	Pazar, Charles E.	584	46.4	53.6
	Holt, Rebecca L.	630	47.5	52.5
Miami	Chapa, Teofilo	250	15.6	84.4
	Lopez-Enriquez, Maria M.	310	21.6	78.4
	Martinez-Esquivel, Lourdes	341	24.3	75.7
	Marks Lane, Denise A.	320	29.7	70.3
	Mart, Herbert Kevin	315	33.7	66.3
	Sanders, Charles J.	130	34.6	65.4
	Torreh-Bayouth, Lilliana	402	37.6	62.4
	Dowell, J. Daniel	200	38.5	61.5
	Alexander, Scott G.	174	41.4	58.6
	Mander, Stephen E.	240	45.8	54.2
	Rodriguez de Jongh, Lourdes A.	141	48.9	51.1
	Solow, Bruce W.	112	49.1	50.9
Miami - Krome	Hurewitz, Kenneth S.	135	2.2	97.8
	Opaciuch, John	317	2.5	97.5
	Ford, Rex J.	503	3.2	96.8
	Opaciuch, Adam	419	6.7	93.3
	Alexander, Scott G.	159	8.2	91.8
	Slavin, Denise N.	147	9.5	90.5
New Orleans	Larocca, Joseph	107	28	72
	Stogner, William Wayne	197	44.2	55.8
New York	Vomacka, Alan A.	907	41	59
	Hom, Sandy K.	1094	42.4	57.6
	Nelson, Barbara A.	1147	47.1	52.9
	Videla, Gabriel C.	292	52.1	47.9
	Christensen, Jesse B.	1511	66.3	33.7
	Poczter, Aviva L.	1500	66.7	33.3
	Cheng, Mary M.	926	69.3	30.7
	Balasquide, Javier E.	1333	77.3	22.7
	Wright, Virna A.	954	77.7	22.3
	Loprest, F. James, Jr.	1287	79	21
	Van Wyke, William Van	987	81.1	18.9
	Segal, Alice	1187	82.9	17.1
	Zagzoug, Randa	1152	83	17
	Rohan, Patricia A.	1553	83.9	16.1
	Elstein, Annette S.	243	84.4	15.6
	Burr, Sarah M.	270	85.9	14.1
	Sichel, Helen J.	1702	86.6	13.4
	Weisel, Robert D.	638	86.8	13.2
	Morace, Philip L.	2136	88.2	11.8
	Mulligan, Thomas J.	946	88.8	11.2
	Chew, George T.	1760	89.6	10.4
	Laforest, Brigitte	1921	90	10
	Schoppert, Douglas B.	1470	90.1	9.9
	Gordon-Uruakpa, Vivienne E.	1512	90.5	9.5
	McManus, Margaret	1860	92.5	7.5
	Cassin, Olivia L.	153	92.8	7.2
	Brennan, Noel A.	2240	94.6	5.4
	Bain, Terry A.	1802	95.3	4.7
	Bukszpan, Joanna M.	1194	95.5	4.5
	Lamb, Elizabeth A.	1625	96.3	3.7
	Leeds, Frederic G.	668	97.8	2.2
New York - DET	Abrams, Steven R.	107	29.9	70.1
Newark	Reichenberg, Margaret R.	213	1.4	98.6
	Finston, Leo A.	211	26.1	73.9
	Garcy, Annie S.	335	63	37
	Riefkohl, Alberto J.	402	75.4	24.6
	Khan, Amiena	211	82	18
	Leeds, Frederic G.	185	84.3	15.7
Oakdale	Reese, Agnelis L.	169	0	100
	Beatmann, Jerry A., Sr.	152	6.6	93.4
	Duck, John A., Jr.	174	6.9	93.1
Omaha	Morris, Daniel A.	390	11.8	88.2
	Anderson, Jack L.	433	20.8	79.2
	Fujimoto, James R.	189	29.6	70.4
Orlando	Grim, James	698	24.8	75.2
	Lippman, Daniel	414	33.3	66.7
	Karden, Stuart F.	425	37.2	62.8
	Ortiz-Segura, Rafael B.	376	42	58
	Chapman, Kevin J.	482	43.4	56.6
	Ghartey, Victoria L.	407	43.5	56.5
Pearsall	Harlow, Craig A.	173	15	85
	Crossan, Thomas G., Jr.	210	19.5	80.5
	Santander, Daniel J.	141	20.6	79.4
Philadelphia	Morley, Steven A.	303	49.5	50.5
	Malloy, Rosalind K.	295	64.7	35.3
	Mills, Miriam K.	272	67.6	32.4
	Honeyman, Charles M.	312	77.6	22.4
Phoenix	Freerks, LaMonte S.	107	36.4	63.6
	Richardson, John W.	161	85.7	14.3
Portland	Sloan, Andrea H.	509	42.4	57.6
	Bennett, Michael H.	503	51.3	48.7
San Antonio	Burkholder, Gary D.	501	3.4	96.6
	Crossan, Thomas G., Jr.	117	17.1	82.9
	McPhaul, Glenn P.	180	39.4	60.6
	Martinez, Anibal D.	267	41.9	58.1
	Zuniga, Bertha A.	250	56	44
	Burkhart, Margaret D.	180	76.1	23.9
San Diego	Clemente, Jesus	256	7	93
	McSeveney, Robert	254	13.4	86.6
	DePaolo, Zsa Zsa	254	42.9	57.1
	Bartolomei, Richard J., Jr	111	44.1	55.9
	Fernandez, Ignacio P.	213	52.1	47.9
	Ipema, Henry P., Jr.	220	53.6	46.4
	Law, Philip S.	114	56.1	43.9
	Renner, Renee L.	298	62.1	37.9
San Francisco	Murry, Anthony S.	514	2.3	97.7
	Yamaguchi, Michael J.	211	4.3	95.7
	Yeargin, Robert	286	45.5	54.5
	Tue, Phan-Quang	229	49.3	50.7
	Teeter, Marilyn J.	235	58.3	41.7
	Maggard, Robert P.	252	61.1	38.9
	Daw, Alison E.	281	63	37
	Geisse, Loreto S.	685	65.7	34.3
	Hayward, Miriam R.	181	65.7	34.3
	Webber, Polly A.	588	66.2	33.8
	Griswold, Stephen S.	622	67.8	32.2
	King, Carol A.	442	71.5	28.5
	Lyons, Joren	499	72.7	27.3
	Hoogasian, Amy C.	316	75	25
	Marks, Dana Leigh	497	82.9	17.1
	Greene, Charles S., III.	112	83	17
	Ramirez, Laura L.	574	84.7	15.3
Seattle	Parchert, Brett M.	543	30	70
	Walsh, John F.	234	38.9	61.1
	Josephson, Kenneth	1203	39.9	60.1
	Kandler, Edward R.	426	41.8	58.2
	Defonzo, Paul A.	658	47.4	52.6
Tacoma	Fitting, Tammy L.	414	26.8	73.2
	Scala, Theresa M.	477	28.5	71.5
	Odell, John C.	289	28.7	71.3
Tucson	Keenan, Sean H.	162	36.4	63.6
	O'Leary, Thomas Michael	163	46.6	53.4
West Valley	Anderson, David C.	115	24.3	75.7
York	Arthur, Andrew R.	187	9.6	90.4
	Bain, Quynh Vu	160	18.1	81.9
	Durling, Walter A.	225	24.4	75.6