Graphical Highlights
 
Judge-by-Judge Asylum Decisions in Immigration Courts
Before and After the Attorney General's Directive

      Denial Rate
Immigration Court Judge Decisions FY2004-FY2006 FY2008-FY2010
New York Hom, Sandy K. 1,345 87.6 66.7
Jankun, William F. 211 86.3 -
Nelson, Barbara A. 1,436 69.6 65.7
Opaciuch, Adam 651 64.1 -
Hladylowycz, Roxanne C. 471 62.6 -
Abrams, Steven R. 813 61.9 60.0
Defonzo, Paul A. 904 56.7 48.2
Videla, Gabriel C. 856 53.0 48.4
Chase, Jeffrey S. 627 50.7 -
Bukszpan, Joanna M. 1,281 47.8 20.0
Ferris, Noel Anne 935 42.8 36.3
Weisel, Robert D. 1,482 36.5 31.8
Mulligan, Thomas J. 1,058 36.1 21.0
Sichel, Helen J. 1,634 34.9 16.2
Morace, Philip L. 2,038 33.9 24.6
Elstein, Annette S. 1,448 29.6 25.8
Schoppert, Douglas B. 1,648 27.8 26.3
Chew, George T. 2,058 26.8 27.2
Holmes-Simmons, Theresa 1,166 26.8 14.1
Burr, Sarah M. 1,257 25.9 30.1
Laforest, Bridgette 1,787 24.7 16.5
Rohan, Patricia A. 1,614 20.9 34.4
Lamb, Elizabeth A. 1,431 20.7 10.6
Brennan, Noel A. 1,678 19.6 9.9
Gordon-Uruakpa, Vivienne E. 1,791 19.3 20.6
Wyke, William Van 1,648 13.2 12.9
McManus, Margaret 1,674 12.2 17.3
Bain, Terry A. 2,035 6.7 6.2
Vomacka, Alan A. 186 - 69.9
Cheng, Mary M. 132 - 39.4
Balasquide, Javier E. 704 - 30.4
Miami Opaciuch, Adam 586 91.4 85.1
Hanson, Mahlon F. 1,187 97.8 85.8
Opaciuch, John 1,223 94.0 77.7
Ford, Rex J. 866 92.0 -
Sanders, Charles J. 1,209 91.2 72.0
Marks Lane, Denise A. 1,352 90.3 82.7
Wilson, Earle B. 398 89.7 -
Metcalf, Mark H. 146 89.0 -
Chapa, Teofilo 1,052 88.6 74.2
Dowell, J. Daniel 1,149 86.4 71.2
Bradley, Kevin G. 881 86.2 68.8
Torreh-Bayouth, Lilliana 1,473 84.6 76.5
Solow, Bruce W. 1,620 81.9 70.9
Holliday, Carey R. 518 81.7 84.2
Sonom, Ronald G. 723 81.5 -
Miranda, Pedro A. 1,354 81.0 59.9
Alexander, Scott G. 1,266 80.9 75.8
McCormack, Nancy R. 1,119 78.2 75.2
Kleinfeld, Seymour R. 484 77.9 -
Sukkar, Elisa M. 721 77.4 60.2
Horn, Michael C. 710 74.2 72.3
Mander, Stephen E. 1,123 67.9 59.7
Randall, Anthony J. 954 67.8 -
Slavin, Denise N. 860 41.2 -
Coleman, Sandra S. 645 24.5 -
Martinez-Esquivel, Lourdes 91 - 87.9
Lopez-Enriquez, Maria 89 - 86.5
Harris, Rodger C. 252 - 81.3
Mateo, Rene D. 95 - 78.9
Crosland, David W. 122 - 69.7
Los Angeles Bither, Christine A. 681 86.9 78.0
Munoz, Lorraine J. 780 83.7 83.8
Romig, Jeffrey L. 476 82.8 -
Giattina, Anthony T. 593 79.2 79.9
Fong, Thomas Y. K. 325 76.5 44.9
Tabaddor, A. Ashley 377 76.2 67.3
Ipema, Henry P., Jr. 117 75.2 -
Latimore, Jan D. 474 72.9 67.6
Ho, Anna 427 69.7 62.8
Bronzina, Isabel A. 522 67.9 59.9
Walton, Richard D. 683 63.7 67.3
Bank, Ira E. 635 62.2 69.3
McDermott, Patrick T. 289 61.2 -
Dunkel-Bradley, Dorothy A. 713 60.3 66.8
Del Bene, Charles A. 103 56.3 -
Renner, Renee L. 298 55.4 -
Walsh, John F. 719 54.3 53.3
Anderson, David C. 715 53.4 42.2
Taylor, John D. 343 50.7 -
Hrycenko, Ingrid K. 181 50.3 -
Stancill, Christine E. 711 47.2 59.2
Proctor, George W. 221 44.8 -
Einhorn, Bruce J. 220 43.6 -
Gembacz, Gilbert T. 325 42.8 -
Sholomson, Stephen L. 547 40.1 41.5
Martin, William J., Jr 389 39.1 47.0
Vahid-Tehrani, Gita 658 33.0 36.5
Parchert, Brett M. 93 - 71.0
Daw, Alison E. 191 - 60.2
DiMarzio, Philip L. 177 - 59.3
Travieso, Frank M. 196 - 59.2
Tsankov, Mimi 277 - 58.5
Bass, Lori R. 127 - 53.5
Sitgraves, D. D. 147 - 53.1
Peters, Rose C. 202 - 51.5
San Francisco Proctor, George W. 108 38.9 -
Murry, Anthony S. 441 91.0 90.8
Hollis, Wendell A. 152 80.9 -
Yeargin, Robert 604 79.3 58.2
Simpson, Brian H. 371 78.7 -
Smith, Gary W. 123 74.8 -
Yam, Mimi Schooley 91 71.4 -
Griswold, Stephen S. 207 62.8 -
Phillips, Beverley M. 396 62.1 -
Kandler, Edward R. 190 62.1 -
Stockton, Bette Kane 817 56.8 71.2
Geisse, Loreto S. 514 55.3 32.2
Tue, Phan-Quang 612 51.6 52.7
Teeter, Marilyn J. 571 50.9 53.6
Gonzalez, Alberto E. 406 50.2 -
Webber, Polly A. 743 46.8 47.9
Yamaguchi, Michael J. 341 46.1 80.6
DiCostanzo, Lawrence N. 580 45.3 54.2
Marks, Dana Leigh 682 40.8 40.1
King, Carol A. 659 38.6 39.4
Ramirez, Laura L. 692 38.4 39.3
Hayward, Miriam R. 711 33.0 47.6
Bernstein, Jeffrey J. 91 - 92.3
Maggard, Print 86 - 47.7
Other courts (by base city):
Arlington Crosland, David W. 184 - 31.0
Churchill, Joan V. 257 75.9 -
Malphrus, Garry D. 322 66.3 54.0
Iskra, Wayne R. 625 56.7 31.2
Bryant, John Milo 527 52.7 20.9
Grant, M. Christopher 269 42.8 -
Schmidt, Paul W. 550 33.6 15.1
Snow, Thomas G. 82 - 34.1
O'Leary, Brian M. 205 - 29.3
Atlanta Sease, Grace A. 169 97.4 82.6
Rast, G. MacKenzie 132 87.9 -
Cassidy, William A. 208 85.6 -
Houser, Wayne K., Jr. 369 83.7 68.6
Johnston, Paul L. 105 76.2 -
Pelletier, Jonathan D. 206 - 86.4
Baltimore Barrett, Bruce M. 1,004 67.3 64.8
Gossart, John F., Jr. 1,052 57.7 50.7
Dornell, Lisa 1,198 53.6 47.9
DuFresne, Jill H. 994 52.5 56.1
Kessler, Elizabeth A. 429 41.0 40.3
Williams, Phillip T. 325 - 39.7
Bloomington Olmanson, Kristin W. 593 75.9 75.9
Dierkes, Joseph R. 633 69.4 69.9
Nickerson, William J., Jr. 114 - 78.1
Boston Shapiro, Leonard I. 792 70.1 57.0
D'Angelo, Matthew J. 350 64.4 51.5
Cramer, Francis L. 556 61.8 59.4
Klein, Eliza C. 815 58.8 55.5
Gagnon, Paul M. 542 56.2 53.0
Sheppard, Patricia M. B. 205 37.6 -
O'Malley, Brenda M. 81 - 63.0
Feder, Robin E. 349 - 59.3
Buffalo Rocco, Michaelangelo 83 96.4 -
Reid, John B. 249 92.3 84.9
Montante, Philip J., Jr 282 75.9 77.7
Charlotte Holmes-Simmons, Theresa 123 - 55.3
Chicago Vinikoor, Robert D. 737 73.5 54.8
Brahos, O. John 183 59.0 -
Zerbe, Craig M. 643 51.9 37.9
Cuevas, Carlos 501 39.3 56.3
Giambastiani, Jennie L. 409 34.7 40.2
Fujimoto, James R. 180 34.4 -
Bower, Glen L. 247 11.8 17.5
Cleveland Harris, Rodger C. 165 - 49.1
Romig, Jeffrey L. 108 - 72.2
Churchill, Joan V. 77 70.1 -
Malphrus, Garry D. 80 81.3 -
Iskra, Wayne R. 135 65.2 -
Bryant, John Milo 241 55.2 -
Grant, M. Christopher 83 72.3 -
Schmidt, Paul W. 103 32.0 -
Snow, Thomas G. 106 73.6 -
O'Leary, Brian M. 76 - 32.9
Janas, Thomas 162 - 82.7
Evans, D. William, Jr. 360 - 81.4
Dallas Sims, Deitrich H. 187 88.8 -
Copeland, Cary H. 321 75.1 -
Hughes, Edwin R. 216 46.3 -
Ozmun, Richard R. 101 - 68.3
Denver Vandello, James P. 155 71.6 -
Livingston, Donn L. 636 60.1 67.0
Cordova, David J. 585 56.0 70.4
Detroit Nettles, Marsha K. 497 89.4 70.5
Hacker, Elizabeth A. 769 83.8 51.0
Newberry, Robert D. 754 82.3 53.7
El Paso Abbott, William L. 224 54.6 83.0
Roepke, Thomas C. 76 - 98.7
Elizabeth Abrams, Steven R. 199 58.3 -
Reichenberg, Margaret R. 260 77.3 -
Tadal, Mirlande 470 76.0 75.3
Harbeck, Dorothy A. 192 - 58.3
Eloy Davis, John W. 89 100.0 -
Keenan, Sean H. 121 100.0 -
Florence Jefferies, Scott M. 216 85.6 86.7
Taylor, Bruce A. 114 - 92.1
Guaynabo Lopez-Defillo, Irma 151 86.8 -
Hagatna Beamer, Dayna M. 163 31.9 -
Hartford D'Angelo, Matthew J. 120 65.8 -
Straus, Michael W. 907 69.8 73.1
Honolulu Beamer, Dayna M. 540 25.9 23.9
Houston Yates, Clarease Rankin 320 87.7 67.2
Brisack, Chris A. 232 81.5 77.5
Peterson, William C. 163 79.8 -
Benton, Jimmie L. 195 77.9 -
Law, Philip S. 504 77.3 76.1
Zimmer, William K. 369 72.4 80.1
Rose, Howard 97 - 100.0
Imperial Staton, Jack W. 200 86.8 85.3
James, Dennis R. 79 - 69.6
Kansas City Vinikoor, Robert D. 104 90.4 -
Lancaster Nickerson, William J., Jr. 136 81.6 -
Vicars, Robert O., Jr. 95 81.1 -
Las Vegas Gastley, Harry L. 312 76.6 64.9
Mullins, Ronald L. 197 72.0 62.0
Weiss, Irene 293 46.0 39.2
Memphis Pazar, Charles E. 1,186 62.8 52.7
Burman, Lawrence O. 948 62.1 30.8
Miami - Krome Ford, Rex J. 245 - 90.6
Slavin, Denise N. 108 - 92.6
Foster, Neale S. 121 96.7 -
Hurewitz, Kenneth S. 741 87.5 98.2
New Orleans Houser, Wayne K., Jr. 84 78.6 -
Stogner, William Wayne 254 55.7 70.1
New York (Detained) Vomacka, Alan A. 340 96.0 92.2
Page, Alan L. 215 81.9 -
Newark Reichenberg, Margaret R. 242 - 70.7
Pugliese, Eugene 617 82.9 72.0
Meisner, Daniel A. 325 82.5 -
Cabrera, Esmeralda 92 76.1 -
Dogin, Henry S. 805 71.2 65.8
Garcy, Annie S. 805 59.9 44.9
Riefkohl, Alberto J. 760 38.0 39.9
Strasser, William K. 208 36.5 -
Roy, Susan Girardo 172 - 72.1
Leeds, Frederic G. 248 - 56.5
Oakdale Duck, John A., Jr. 130 76.9 -
Omaha Cuevas, Carlos 108 83.3 -
Fujimoto, James R. 530 78.5 82.7
Morris, Daniel A. 79 - 92.4
Anderson, Jack L. 125 - 78.4
Orlando Wilson, Earle B. 822 - 80.7
McHugh, R. Kevin 127 84.3 -
Padgett, Gail B. 211 78.7 -
Ortiz-Segura, Rafael B. 1,913 49.8 54.6
Smith, Renetta 481 44.1 -
Ghartey, Victoria L. 1,735 41.2 50.2
Grim, James 258 - 83.3
Lippman, Daniel 462 - 78.6
Chapman, Kevin J. 540 - 77.6
Philadelphia Ferlise, Donald V. 470 88.3 -
Malloy, Rosalind K. 918 81.7 56.3
Mills, Miriam K. 641 79.8 53.4
Honeyman, Charles M. 831 69.0 40.5
Phoenix Hollis, Wendell A. 206 49.4 69.9
Freerks, LaMonte S. 394 26.8 44.4
Richardson, John W. 241 17.0 18.4
Portland Bennett, Michael H. 626 63.9 67.2
Salt Lake City Nixon, William L. 180 51.3 64.0
Pead, Dustin B. 86 - 59.3
San Antonio McPhaul, Glenn P. 231 57.4 52.0
Zuniga, Bertha A. 248 42.5 39.9
Burkholder, Gary D. 142 - 85.2
Conley de Castro, Susan E. 121 - 68.6
Carte, John D. 107 - 36.4
San Diego Ipema, Henry P., Jr. 169 68.7 55.8
Renner, Renee L. 212 - 34.9
Bagley, Kenneth A. 292 75.4 36.7
DePaolo, Zsa Zsa 427 71.6 22.6
Atenaide, Anthony M. 391 65.2 34.2
Bartolomei, Richard J., Jr 306 64.4 44.8
Fernandez, Ignacio P. 295 63.3 28.2
Barrett, Robert J. 145 39.3 -
Williams, John C. 242 30.2 29.3
San Pedro Sitgraves, D. D. 128 76.6 -
Peters, Rose C. 101 45.5 -
Seattle Defonzo, Paul A. 150 - 56.7
Kandler, Edward R. 758 65.9 64.6
Josephson, Kenneth 1,214 61.3 59.3
Tacoma Josephson, Kenneth 96 78.1 -
Young, Victoria E. 91 89.0 -
Fitting, Tammy L. 117 - 80.3
Tucson Knuck, Richard H. 122 8.2 -
York Sease, Grace A. 213 88.3 -
Durling, Walter A. 296 78.6 76.0
Arthur, Andrew R. 101 - 99.0

* As recorded in the Executive Office for Immigration Review files as of June 21, 2010.
Thus, figures for FY 2010 cover only a partial year.


Transactional Records Access Clearinghouse, Syracuse University
Copyright 2010