Judge-by-Judge Asylum Decisions by Immigration Court Fiscal Years 2001 - 2006
|
665 |
91.6 |
7 |
1,532 |
89.7 |
12 |
879 |
87.5 |
21 |
381 |
79.3 |
50 |
369 |
77.2 |
63 |
1,416 |
72.2 |
82 |
1,518 |
71.7 |
84 |
1,669 |
70.2 |
92 |
401 |
69.8 |
96 |
377 |
60.7 |
131 |
1,168 |
60.6 |
134 |
600 |
60.3 |
138 |
1,388 |
60.3 |
138 |
645 |
51.9 |
165 |
100 |
50.0 |
171 |
1,076 |
49.4 |
176 |
1,347 |
48.0 |
180 |
939 |
43.7 |
189 |
1,677 |
42.9 |
193 |
1,514 |
42.0 |
197 |
2,294 |
39.6 |
202 |
162 |
37.7 |
210 |
1,989 |
34.7 |
215 |
236 |
34.7 |
215 |
1,767 |
31.0 |
221 |
2,221 |
29.8 |
223 |
1,689 |
28.8 |
224 |
1,840 |
28.5 |
225 |
1,937 |
28.2 |
227 |
1,718 |
25.3 |
231 |
1,381 |
22.1 |
233 |
1,966 |
21.9 |
234 |
810 |
20.4 |
237 |
1,181 |
14.7 |
240 |
1,859 |
9.9 |
241 |
1,946 |
9.5 |
242 |
1,388 |
97.6 |
1 |
902 |
93.6 |
6 |
306 |
91.2 |
9 |
141 |
90.8 |
10 |
1,544 |
90.7 |
11 |
386 |
89.6 |
13 |
1,684 |
88.0 |
16 |
558 |
87.8 |
19 |
1,074 |
87.8 |
19 |
1,372 |
87.5 |
21 |
1,413 |
87.0 |
24 |
1,421 |
86.3 |
28 |
1,175 |
82.1 |
35 |
1,544 |
81.5 |
37 |
1,342 |
79.7 |
47 |
184 |
79.3 |
50 |
1,360 |
79.1 |
52 |
1,386 |
78.0 |
58 |
1,630 |
76.0 |
71 |
1,217 |
73.0 |
79 |
971 |
70.4 |
90 |
875 |
70.1 |
93 |
1,470 |
69.0 |
98 |
1,364 |
62.9 |
118 |
1,541 |
38.9 |
204 |
1,158 |
21.8 |
235 |
442 |
86.7 |
27 |
647 |
80.8 |
40 |
538 |
80.5 |
43 |
403 |
78.7 |
57 |
375 |
77.6 |
60 |
351 |
76.9 |
67 |
610 |
72.6 |
80 |
441 |
70.7 |
89 |
239 |
67.4 |
104 |
644 |
64.0 |
115 |
102 |
63.7 |
116 |
685 |
62.5 |
121 |
416 |
61.1 |
128 |
938 |
61.0 |
130 |
611 |
60.6 |
134 |
345 |
60.6 |
134 |
162 |
60.5 |
135 |
484 |
59.5 |
145 |
693 |
58.7 |
147 |
139 |
57.6 |
150 |
494 |
54.3 |
155 |
328 |
49.7 |
173 |
271 |
49.4 |
176 |
723 |
48.5 |
178 |
522 |
46.0 |
184 |
516 |
45.2 |
185 |
485 |
40.2 |
201 |
708 |
38.8 |
206 |
590 |
38.3 |
207 |
266 |
38.0 |
209 |
663 |
27.1 |
229 |
527 |
86.7 |
27 |
229 |
79.5 |
48 |
516 |
78.7 |
57 |
698 |
77.1 |
64 |
122 |
74.6 |
75 |
341 |
72.4 |
81 |
204 |
62.7 |
120 |
743 |
59.0 |
146 |
303 |
55.8 |
153 |
866 |
53.9 |
156 |
671 |
53.4 |
158 |
941 |
51.3 |
166 |
255 |
49.4 |
176 |
903 |
46.2 |
183 |
605 |
45.1 |
187 |
734 |
42.8 |
194 |
939 |
41.4 |
198 |
448 |
39.5 |
203 |
104 |
35.6 |
212 |
747 |
34.8 |
213 |
846 |
31.4 |
220 |
789 |
30.8 |
222 |
785 |
26.5 |
230 |
733 |
76.9 |
67 |
181 |
70.7 |
89 |
893 |
61.0 |
130 |
123 |
60.2 |
139 |
885 |
59.7 |
143 |
561 |
50.4 |
169 |
427 |
33.5 |
217 |
366 |
82.5 |
34 |
208 |
81.3 |
38 |
303 |
80.5 |
43 |
283 |
79.2 |
51 |
1,428 |
63.2 |
117 |
1,250 |
59.6 |
144 |
1,304 |
57.5 |
151 |
1,467 |
49.8 |
172 |
142 |
38.0 |
209 |
599 |
73.0 |
79 |
849 |
64.7 |
110 |
243 |
85.6 |
29 |
146 |
65.1 |
109 |
845 |
64.4 |
112 |
311 |
61.1 |
128 |
912 |
58.1 |
148 |
373 |
52.0 |
164 |
584 |
50.2 |
170 |
245 |
38.8 |
206 |
202 |
93.6 |
6 |
355 |
77.2 |
63 |
607 |
70.8 |
86 |
884 |
69.9 |
94 |
239 |
67.8 |
101 |
807 |
65.1 |
109 |
817 |
55.8 |
153 |
694 |
49.0 |
177 |
417 |
47.7 |
181 |
143 |
43.4 |
190 |
299 |
84.3 |
30 |
888 |
67.7 |
102 |
486 |
42.0 |
197 |
385 |
61.8 |
125 |
677 |
55.2 |
154 |
654 |
50.9 |
167 |
250 |
89.2 |
14 |
111 |
87.4 |
22 |
902 |
81.5 |
37 |
103 |
77.7 |
59 |
1,301 |
70.2 |
92 |
139 |
60.4 |
136 |
109 |
43.1 |
191 |
471 |
70.7 |
89 |
663 |
67.6 |
103 |
733 |
62.1 |
124 |
122 |
34.4 |
216 |
192 |
80.2 |
44 |
410 |
31.5 |
219 |
159 |
69.8 |
96 |
943 |
69.1 |
97 |
191 |
52.4 |
162 |
309 |
27.5 |
228 |
467 |
78.8 |
54 |
250 |
76.8 |
68 |
270 |
76.3 |
69 |
416 |
76.0 |
71 |
430 |
74.0 |
76 |
213 |
60.1 |
140 |
168 |
94.0 |
4 |
139 |
80.6 |
41 |
195 |
75.9 |
72 |
335 |
77.3 |
61 |
173 |
71.7 |
84 |
256 |
43.0 |
192 |
1,293 |
61.1 |
128 |
890 |
59.8 |
142 |
218 |
95.0 |
3 |
170 |
91.2 |
9 |
740 |
87.2 |
23 |
102 |
48.0 |
180 |
182 |
76.9 |
67 |
574 |
96.5 |
2 |
444 |
83.8 |
33 |
652 |
80.8 |
40 |
605 |
78.7 |
57 |
1,184 |
65.5 |
107 |
210 |
64.3 |
113 |
813 |
57.9 |
149 |
921 |
36.2 |
211 |
398 |
28.4 |
226 |
108 |
71.3 |
85 |
180 |
86.7 |
27 |
139 |
84.2 |
31 |
199 |
79.9 |
46 |
2,082 |
50.7 |
168 |
605 |
45.1 |
187 |
1,024 |
41.2 |
199 |
631 |
41.0 |
200 |
988 |
88.9 |
15 |
461 |
79.0 |
53 |
1,065 |
74.9 |
74 |
1,008 |
62.8 |
119 |
248 |
52.4 |
162 |
120 |
19.2 |
238 |
307 |
32.9 |
218 |
144 |
22.2 |
232 |
337 |
21.7 |
236 |
455 |
52.7 |
160 |
109 |
53.2 |
159 |
161 |
52.2 |
163 |
325 |
75.4 |
73 |
115 |
73.0 |
79 |
198 |
67.2 |
106 |
152 |
64.5 |
111 |
361 |
64.0 |
115 |
426 |
62.4 |
122 |
260 |
60.0 |
141 |
292 |
44.2 |
188 |
311 |
42.4 |
195 |
103 |
53.4 |
158 |
153 |
46.4 |
182 |
105 |
83.8 |
33 |
229 |
79.9 |
46 |
148 |
68.9 |
99 |
351 |
67.2 |
106 |
995 |
62.1 |
124 |
144 |
15.3 |
239 |
237 |
87.8 |
19 |
351 |
68.4 |
100 |
* Judge-to-judge differences in asylum denial rates within this Immigration Court are "statistically significant" -- that is, unlikely to have arisen by chance where asylum cases are assigned at random among judges. "Unlikely" means there was less than a one in ten thousand (<.0001) chance except for three cities (Bloomingdale, Denver, Phoenix) where the odds were less than 3 out of a thousand. Analysis covers all immigration judges who made at least 100 decisions on the merits for asylum seekers represented by an attorney.
|
Transactional Records Access Clearinghouse, Syracuse University
Copyright 2007